Actor Suriya’s NEET Remark not contempt but Unnecessary – Madras High Court || hybiz.tv
#ActorSuriya #Neet #MadrasHighCourt #SuriyaSivakumar #NeetExams #SouthActorSuriya
Actor Suriya had said that courts are delivering justice through video conferencing due to life-threatening coronavirus fears but are ordering students to write the exams fearlessly.
The Madras High Court bench observed that actor Suriya’s NEET remarks do not amount to contempt or a level of criminal contempt but termed them “absolutely unnecessary”.
The Madras High Court Friday declined to initiate contempt proceedings against actor Suriya for his comments on the Supreme Court’s decision to allow the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) during the Covid-19 pandemic.
The principal bench observed that the actor’s remarks do not amount to contempt or a level of criminal contempt but termed them “absolutely unnecessary”.
“It would be prudent on the part of the individuals to carefully frame their minds and express themselves that may not cross the borders of any fair and just criticism. On the other hand, it is not the job of a constitutional Court to use a sledgehammer for avoidance of something which can be perceived to be not capable of even being propped up as a contempt, much less debated to the level of a criminal contempt. This matter, therefore, in our judicious discretion does not deserve to be pursued further and we entirely agree with opinions expressed by the Advocate General,” the court said.
The court added the right to freedom of speech to call a spade a spade and to exercise free unrestrained speech are two different dimensions. It added that the right to freedom of speech that includes fair criticism is guaranteed under the Indian Constitution, but the same Constitution also protects and insulates judicial governance from insidious and derogatory comments under Article 215 of the Constitution.
“Drawing support from what we have expressed hereinabove, we find the utterances by the cine actor may have been absolutely unnecessary or even unwarranted, for being ignorant of the manner in which the entire judiciary of this State has served the interest of its citizens during this pandemic, and any such statement could have been avoided in a much more sober way, instead of an accusing tone, which through trivial nature has raised a storm in a tea cup,” the court observed.
On September 13, actor Suriya had issued a statement following the alleged suicide of three NEET aspirants in Tamil Nadu. He had said the three deaths had shaken his conscience. “A government that was supposed to ensure equal opportunities for everyone brought a law with an education system that creates inequality,”.
He had said that courts are delivering justice through video conferencing due to life-threatening coronavirus fears but are ordering students to write the exams fearlessly.
This part of his statement had offended Justice SM Subramaniam of the Madras High Court who sought to initiate contempt of court against Suriya as his statement found to be “offensive to the judicial system in general”.
HyBiz Tv is India’s most watched Digital Business Channel with over One Million regular viewers. In the 10 years of its existence, HyBiz Tv has provided a platform for business houses to promote, project and propagate their products and services. Corporate videos, promotional videos, interviews, ad- films, events coverage, current relevant news, meaningful discussions on contemporary subjects have given the audience relevant content which has helped in the rapid growth of the viewership. Clients from both the Telugu states and across the country have reaped rich dividends by engaging HyBiz Tv and now this has spread all over the country..
► Watch More Business Videos at India’s Leading online business channel http://www.hybiz.tv
► like us on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/hybiz
► Watch More Videos on http://www.youtube.com/hybiztv
► Subscribe to HYBIZTV Channel: goo.gl/EEXqfu
►Follow us on Twitter https://twitter.com/hybiztv